Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia
Аутори
Dente, Maria GraziaRiccardo, Flavia
Bolici, Francesco
Colella, Nello Augusto
Jovanović, Verica
Drakulović, Mitra
Vasić, Milena
Mamlouk, Habiba
Maazaoui, Latifa
Bejaoui, Mondher
Zakhashvili, Khatuna
Kalandadze, Irine
Imnadze, Paata
Declich, Silvia
Knjeginić, Vesna
Stojković, Borka
Labus, Tatjana
Milicević, Vesna
Veljović, Ljubiša
Maksimović-Zorić, Jelena
Stoiljković, Vera
Filipović-Vignjević, Svetlana
Protić, Jelena
Zgomba, Marija
Petrić, Dusan
Despot, Dragana
Pesić, Branislav
Serović, Katarina
Aleksić, Ivan
Đurić, Ivana
Ilić, Dragan
Vrga, Svetlana
Pavlović, Ljiljana
Plavsa, Dragana
Grego, Edita
Harabech, Kaouther
Ben Alaya, Nissaf
Bougatef, Souha
Triki, Henda
Bouattour, Ali
Rebhi, Mohamed
Daaboub, Jabeur
Somai, Lamia
Zerlli, Malek
Zerlli, Malek
Oukaili, Kaouther
Ammar, Heni Haj
Sghaier, Chedia
Fatnassi, Naouel
Kalthoum, Sana
Dhaouadi, Anissa
Ben Youness, Abdelhak
Mahale, Issam
Marzouk, Mongi
Ben Bdira, Sassi
Grira, Samia
Ayadi, Sonia
Mastouri, Maha
Faten, Allad
Abdelkader, Ben
Chakhunashvili, Giorgi
Babuadze, Giorgi
Mamuchishvili, Nana
Chanturia, Gvantsa
Adeishvili, Ekaterine
Avaliani, Lasha
Ninidze, Lena
Kartskhia, Natia
Gulbani, Ana
Kokhreidze, Maka
Donduashvili, Marina
Kekelidze, Anna
Чланак у часопису (Објављена верзија)
Метаподаци
Приказ свих података о документуАпстракт
Background In the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region, arbovirus infections are emerging infectious diseases. Their surveillance can benefit from one health inter-sectoral collaboration; however, no standardized methodology exists to study One Health surveillance. Methods We designed a situation analysis study to document how integration of laboratory/clinical human, animal and entomological surveillance of arboviruses was being implemented in the Region. We applied a framework designed to assess three levels of integration: policy/institutional, data collection/data analysis and dissemination. We tested the use of Business Process Modelling Notation (BPMN) to graphically present evidence of inter-sectoral integration. Results Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia participated in the study. West Nile Virus surveillance was analysed in Serbia and Tunisia, Crimea-Congo Haemorrhagic Fever surveillance in Georgia. Our framework enabled a standardized analysis of One Health surveillance integration, a...nd BPMN was easily understandable and conducive to detailed discussions among different actors/institutions. In all countries, we observed integration across sectors and levels except in data collection and data analysis. Data collection was interoperable only in Georgia without integrated analysis. In all countries, surveillance was mainly oriented towards outbreak response, triggered by an index human case. Discussion The three surveillance systems we observed prove that integrated surveillance can be operationalized with a diverse spectrum of options. However, in all countries, the integrated use of data for early warning and inter-sectoral priority setting is pioneeristic. We also noted that early warning before human case occurrence is recurrently not operationally prioritized.
Кључне речи:
arboviruses / Crimean Congo Haemorrhagic Fever / One Health / surveillance / vector-borne infections / West Nile virusИзвор:
Zoonoses and Public Health, 2019, 66, 3, 276-287Издавач:
- Wiley, Hoboken
Финансирање / пројекти:
- European Union DEVCOEuropean Union (EU) [IFS/21010/23/-194]
DOI: 10.1111/zph.12562
ISSN: 1863-1959
PubMed: 30724030
WoS: 000464342300002
Scopus: 2-s2.0-85061025963
Институција/група
TorlakTY - JOUR AU - Dente, Maria Grazia AU - Riccardo, Flavia AU - Bolici, Francesco AU - Colella, Nello Augusto AU - Jovanović, Verica AU - Drakulović, Mitra AU - Vasić, Milena AU - Mamlouk, Habiba AU - Maazaoui, Latifa AU - Bejaoui, Mondher AU - Zakhashvili, Khatuna AU - Kalandadze, Irine AU - Imnadze, Paata AU - Declich, Silvia AU - Knjeginić, Vesna AU - Stojković, Borka AU - Labus, Tatjana AU - Milicević, Vesna AU - Veljović, Ljubiša AU - Maksimović-Zorić, Jelena AU - Stoiljković, Vera AU - Filipović-Vignjević, Svetlana AU - Protić, Jelena AU - Zgomba, Marija AU - Petrić, Dusan AU - Despot, Dragana AU - Pesić, Branislav AU - Serović, Katarina AU - Aleksić, Ivan AU - Đurić, Ivana AU - Ilić, Dragan AU - Vrga, Svetlana AU - Pavlović, Ljiljana AU - Plavsa, Dragana AU - Grego, Edita AU - Harabech, Kaouther AU - Ben Alaya, Nissaf AU - Bougatef, Souha AU - Triki, Henda AU - Bouattour, Ali AU - Rebhi, Mohamed AU - Daaboub, Jabeur AU - Somai, Lamia AU - Zerlli, Malek AU - Zerlli, Malek AU - Oukaili, Kaouther AU - Ammar, Heni Haj AU - Sghaier, Chedia AU - Fatnassi, Naouel AU - Kalthoum, Sana AU - Dhaouadi, Anissa AU - Ben Youness, Abdelhak AU - Mahale, Issam AU - Marzouk, Mongi AU - Ben Bdira, Sassi AU - Grira, Samia AU - Ayadi, Sonia AU - Mastouri, Maha AU - Faten, Allad AU - Abdelkader, Ben AU - Chakhunashvili, Giorgi AU - Babuadze, Giorgi AU - Mamuchishvili, Nana AU - Chanturia, Gvantsa AU - Adeishvili, Ekaterine AU - Avaliani, Lasha AU - Ninidze, Lena AU - Kartskhia, Natia AU - Gulbani, Ana AU - Kokhreidze, Maka AU - Donduashvili, Marina AU - Kekelidze, Anna PY - 2019 UR - http://intor.torlakinstitut.com/handle/123456789/535 AB - Background In the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region, arbovirus infections are emerging infectious diseases. Their surveillance can benefit from one health inter-sectoral collaboration; however, no standardized methodology exists to study One Health surveillance. Methods We designed a situation analysis study to document how integration of laboratory/clinical human, animal and entomological surveillance of arboviruses was being implemented in the Region. We applied a framework designed to assess three levels of integration: policy/institutional, data collection/data analysis and dissemination. We tested the use of Business Process Modelling Notation (BPMN) to graphically present evidence of inter-sectoral integration. Results Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia participated in the study. West Nile Virus surveillance was analysed in Serbia and Tunisia, Crimea-Congo Haemorrhagic Fever surveillance in Georgia. Our framework enabled a standardized analysis of One Health surveillance integration, and BPMN was easily understandable and conducive to detailed discussions among different actors/institutions. In all countries, we observed integration across sectors and levels except in data collection and data analysis. Data collection was interoperable only in Georgia without integrated analysis. In all countries, surveillance was mainly oriented towards outbreak response, triggered by an index human case. Discussion The three surveillance systems we observed prove that integrated surveillance can be operationalized with a diverse spectrum of options. However, in all countries, the integrated use of data for early warning and inter-sectoral priority setting is pioneeristic. We also noted that early warning before human case occurrence is recurrently not operationally prioritized. PB - Wiley, Hoboken T2 - Zoonoses and Public Health T1 - Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia EP - 287 IS - 3 SP - 276 VL - 66 DO - 10.1111/zph.12562 ER -
@article{ author = "Dente, Maria Grazia and Riccardo, Flavia and Bolici, Francesco and Colella, Nello Augusto and Jovanović, Verica and Drakulović, Mitra and Vasić, Milena and Mamlouk, Habiba and Maazaoui, Latifa and Bejaoui, Mondher and Zakhashvili, Khatuna and Kalandadze, Irine and Imnadze, Paata and Declich, Silvia and Knjeginić, Vesna and Stojković, Borka and Labus, Tatjana and Milicević, Vesna and Veljović, Ljubiša and Maksimović-Zorić, Jelena and Stoiljković, Vera and Filipović-Vignjević, Svetlana and Protić, Jelena and Zgomba, Marija and Petrić, Dusan and Despot, Dragana and Pesić, Branislav and Serović, Katarina and Aleksić, Ivan and Đurić, Ivana and Ilić, Dragan and Vrga, Svetlana and Pavlović, Ljiljana and Plavsa, Dragana and Grego, Edita and Harabech, Kaouther and Ben Alaya, Nissaf and Bougatef, Souha and Triki, Henda and Bouattour, Ali and Rebhi, Mohamed and Daaboub, Jabeur and Somai, Lamia and Zerlli, Malek and Zerlli, Malek and Oukaili, Kaouther and Ammar, Heni Haj and Sghaier, Chedia and Fatnassi, Naouel and Kalthoum, Sana and Dhaouadi, Anissa and Ben Youness, Abdelhak and Mahale, Issam and Marzouk, Mongi and Ben Bdira, Sassi and Grira, Samia and Ayadi, Sonia and Mastouri, Maha and Faten, Allad and Abdelkader, Ben and Chakhunashvili, Giorgi and Babuadze, Giorgi and Mamuchishvili, Nana and Chanturia, Gvantsa and Adeishvili, Ekaterine and Avaliani, Lasha and Ninidze, Lena and Kartskhia, Natia and Gulbani, Ana and Kokhreidze, Maka and Donduashvili, Marina and Kekelidze, Anna", year = "2019", abstract = "Background In the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region, arbovirus infections are emerging infectious diseases. Their surveillance can benefit from one health inter-sectoral collaboration; however, no standardized methodology exists to study One Health surveillance. Methods We designed a situation analysis study to document how integration of laboratory/clinical human, animal and entomological surveillance of arboviruses was being implemented in the Region. We applied a framework designed to assess three levels of integration: policy/institutional, data collection/data analysis and dissemination. We tested the use of Business Process Modelling Notation (BPMN) to graphically present evidence of inter-sectoral integration. Results Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia participated in the study. West Nile Virus surveillance was analysed in Serbia and Tunisia, Crimea-Congo Haemorrhagic Fever surveillance in Georgia. Our framework enabled a standardized analysis of One Health surveillance integration, and BPMN was easily understandable and conducive to detailed discussions among different actors/institutions. In all countries, we observed integration across sectors and levels except in data collection and data analysis. Data collection was interoperable only in Georgia without integrated analysis. In all countries, surveillance was mainly oriented towards outbreak response, triggered by an index human case. Discussion The three surveillance systems we observed prove that integrated surveillance can be operationalized with a diverse spectrum of options. However, in all countries, the integrated use of data for early warning and inter-sectoral priority setting is pioneeristic. We also noted that early warning before human case occurrence is recurrently not operationally prioritized.", publisher = "Wiley, Hoboken", journal = "Zoonoses and Public Health", title = "Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia", pages = "287-276", number = "3", volume = "66", doi = "10.1111/zph.12562" }
Dente, M. G., Riccardo, F., Bolici, F., Colella, N. A., Jovanović, V., Drakulović, M., Vasić, M., Mamlouk, H., Maazaoui, L., Bejaoui, M., Zakhashvili, K., Kalandadze, I., Imnadze, P., Declich, S., Knjeginić, V., Stojković, B., Labus, T., Milicević, V., Veljović, L., Maksimović-Zorić, J., Stoiljković, V., Filipović-Vignjević, S., Protić, J., Zgomba, M., Petrić, D., Despot, D., Pesić, B., Serović, K., Aleksić, I., Đurić, I., Ilić, D., Vrga, S., Pavlović, L., Plavsa, D., Grego, E., Harabech, K., Ben Alaya, N., Bougatef, S., Triki, H., Bouattour, A., Rebhi, M., Daaboub, J., Somai, L., Zerlli, M., Zerlli, M., Oukaili, K., Ammar, H. H., Sghaier, C., Fatnassi, N., Kalthoum, S., Dhaouadi, A., Ben Youness, A., Mahale, I., Marzouk, M., Ben Bdira, S., Grira, S., Ayadi, S., Mastouri, M., Faten, A., Abdelkader, B., Chakhunashvili, G., Babuadze, G., Mamuchishvili, N., Chanturia, G., Adeishvili, E., Avaliani, L., Ninidze, L., Kartskhia, N., Gulbani, A., Kokhreidze, M., Donduashvili, M.,& Kekelidze, A.. (2019). Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia. in Zoonoses and Public Health Wiley, Hoboken., 66(3), 276-287. https://doi.org/10.1111/zph.12562
Dente MG, Riccardo F, Bolici F, Colella NA, Jovanović V, Drakulović M, Vasić M, Mamlouk H, Maazaoui L, Bejaoui M, Zakhashvili K, Kalandadze I, Imnadze P, Declich S, Knjeginić V, Stojković B, Labus T, Milicević V, Veljović L, Maksimović-Zorić J, Stoiljković V, Filipović-Vignjević S, Protić J, Zgomba M, Petrić D, Despot D, Pesić B, Serović K, Aleksić I, Đurić I, Ilić D, Vrga S, Pavlović L, Plavsa D, Grego E, Harabech K, Ben Alaya N, Bougatef S, Triki H, Bouattour A, Rebhi M, Daaboub J, Somai L, Zerlli M, Zerlli M, Oukaili K, Ammar HH, Sghaier C, Fatnassi N, Kalthoum S, Dhaouadi A, Ben Youness A, Mahale I, Marzouk M, Ben Bdira S, Grira S, Ayadi S, Mastouri M, Faten A, Abdelkader B, Chakhunashvili G, Babuadze G, Mamuchishvili N, Chanturia G, Adeishvili E, Avaliani L, Ninidze L, Kartskhia N, Gulbani A, Kokhreidze M, Donduashvili M, Kekelidze A. Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia. in Zoonoses and Public Health. 2019;66(3):276-287. doi:10.1111/zph.12562 .
Dente, Maria Grazia, Riccardo, Flavia, Bolici, Francesco, Colella, Nello Augusto, Jovanović, Verica, Drakulović, Mitra, Vasić, Milena, Mamlouk, Habiba, Maazaoui, Latifa, Bejaoui, Mondher, Zakhashvili, Khatuna, Kalandadze, Irine, Imnadze, Paata, Declich, Silvia, Knjeginić, Vesna, Stojković, Borka, Labus, Tatjana, Milicević, Vesna, Veljović, Ljubiša, Maksimović-Zorić, Jelena, Stoiljković, Vera, Filipović-Vignjević, Svetlana, Protić, Jelena, Zgomba, Marija, Petrić, Dusan, Despot, Dragana, Pesić, Branislav, Serović, Katarina, Aleksić, Ivan, Đurić, Ivana, Ilić, Dragan, Vrga, Svetlana, Pavlović, Ljiljana, Plavsa, Dragana, Grego, Edita, Harabech, Kaouther, Ben Alaya, Nissaf, Bougatef, Souha, Triki, Henda, Bouattour, Ali, Rebhi, Mohamed, Daaboub, Jabeur, Somai, Lamia, Zerlli, Malek, Zerlli, Malek, Oukaili, Kaouther, Ammar, Heni Haj, Sghaier, Chedia, Fatnassi, Naouel, Kalthoum, Sana, Dhaouadi, Anissa, Ben Youness, Abdelhak, Mahale, Issam, Marzouk, Mongi, Ben Bdira, Sassi, Grira, Samia, Ayadi, Sonia, Mastouri, Maha, Faten, Allad, Abdelkader, Ben, Chakhunashvili, Giorgi, Babuadze, Giorgi, Mamuchishvili, Nana, Chanturia, Gvantsa, Adeishvili, Ekaterine, Avaliani, Lasha, Ninidze, Lena, Kartskhia, Natia, Gulbani, Ana, Kokhreidze, Maka, Donduashvili, Marina, Kekelidze, Anna, "Implementation of the One Health approach to fight arbovirus infections in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Region: Assessing integrated surveillance in Serbia, Tunisia and Georgia" in Zoonoses and Public Health, 66, no. 3 (2019):276-287, https://doi.org/10.1111/zph.12562 . .